Kafka vs RabbitMQ Architecture Performance & Use Cases

Apache Kafka and RabbitMQ

Apache Kafka and RabbitMQ are two open-source message broker and commercially-supported pub/sub asynchronous processing systems. RabbitMQ can use as a message broker between microservices.

RabbitMQ Architecture

RabbitMQ is one of the most widely used open-source message brokers. It was originally based on the Advanced Message Queuing Protocol (AMQP).In the RabbitMQ architecture main components are Producer ,Exchange ,Queue and Consumer application.


In here we will take a use case example to understand better how RabbitMQ components are work each other.

Use Case: In this system when user create an doctor appointment ,system should be able to trigger an email to the relevant parties. In this cluster lets say we have couple of queues  patient-notification(notify to the patient) , doctor-notification(notify to the doctor) , admin-notification(notify to the hospital administration).

Producer: 
Producing means nothing more than sending a messages .A producer pushes messages to exchanges. 
Ex: Producer is a web base application, once user create an appointment ,producer send a message to queue ,In this message object include email details. 

Exchange
It is basically a routing rule for the messages. Messages are not published directly to a queue; instead, the producer sends messages to an exchange. An exchange is responsible for routing the messages to different queues with the help of bindings and routing keys. A binding is a link between a queue and an exchange. There are four types of Exchanges.

        Direct: The message is routed to the queues whose binding key exactly matches the routing key of the message. Ex: If the queue is bound to the exchange with the binding key patient-notification, a message published to the exchange with a routing key patient-notification is routed to that queue. It will send email to patient.

        Fanout: A fanout exchange routes messages to all of the queues bound to it. Ex: When the user create an appointment ,It will route to all the queues ,that means send an email to patient ,doctor and hospital administration.
                      

           Topic: The topic exchange does a wildcard match between the routing key and the     routing pattern specified in the binding. Ex: If the user cancel the appointment ,system only needs to send an email to doctor and hospital administration.so message push to doctor-notification ,admin-notification.

       Headers: Headers exchanges use the message header attributes for routing.


Queue
A queue is a line of things waiting to be handled, starting at the beginning of the line and processing it in sequential order.




A message queue is a queue of messages sent between applications. It includes a sequence of work objects that are waiting to be processed.

A message is the data transported between the sender and the receiver application; it's essentially a byte array with some headers at the top.

The basic architecture of a message queue is simple; there are client applications called producers that create messages and deliver them to the message queue. Another application, called a consumer, connects to the queue and gets the messages to be processed. Messages placed onto the queue are stored until the consumer retrieves them. Once consumer consumed the message successfully ,consumer send ack(acknowledgment) to the queue ,then RabbitMQ will delete the message from the  queue.

A message queue provides an asynchronous communications protocol, which is a system that puts a message onto a message queue and does not require an immediate response to continuing processing. Message Queue contains FIFO (first in first out) if there is no priority queue.
 
Consumer
Consumer also known as a subscriber. It reads messages from the queues and send the ack to the RabbitMQ.
Ex: In our use case consumer is application , it will get the email message object from the queue and process the object check the validation of the email object ,send a email to the end user.


Basic

RabbitMQ is solid , mature ,general purpose message broker. It support Publish/ Subscribe and asynchronous processing.

Price

open source; it's free to use.

Primary use

A common use case for RabbitMQ is to handle background jobs or long-running task, such as file scanning, image scaling or PDF conversion.

System simply needs to notify another part of the system (send an email/SMS notification)

Message handling


RabbitMQ, messages are stored until a receiving application connects and receives a message off the queue.

RabbitMQ use the RAM to store the message , when the message queue does not have any event/message it can be fast.(Openshift/Kubernetes use Persistent Storage)

Protocol

It supports several protocols such as AMQP, MQTT, STOMP

Scaling

RabbitMQ is mostly designed for vertical scaling (scale by adding more power ,CPU).


Routing

RabbitMQ has route messages in complex ways to the consumers.

direct, topic, fanout, and header exchanges


Monitor

RabbitMQ has a built-in user-friendly interface that lets you monitor and handle your RabbitMQ server from a web browser.




Kafka Architecture

Kafka is an open-source event streaming platform first developed by LinkedIn, then donated to the Apache software foundation. Apache Kafka aims to provide the user with a unified, high latency, high throughput platform for handling real-time data. 

As we talk about running Kafka on Kubernetes - Kafka runs as a cluster of nodes called Kafka brokers. Kafka was developed first as a messaging queue and works as a pub-sub model. It’s used as a popular message queue for distributed systems, and is commonly used to stream data in the Internet of Things use cases.


Basic

Apache Kafka is a message bus optimized for high-ingress data streams and replay. It is event streaming platform.

Publish / subscribe and asynchronous processing

Price

open source; it's free to use.

Primary use

Use Kafka when we need to move a large amount of data, process data in real-time or analyze data over a time period.

An example is when we want to track user activity on a web-shop and generate suggested items to buy.


Message handling

The message queue in Kafka is persistent. Kafka actually stores all of its records to disk and does not keep anything in RAM.

That mean message is not removed once it’s consumed ,It can be replayed or consumed multiple times.

Protocol

Kafka uses a custom protocol on top of TCP/IP

Scaling

Kafka is built from the ground up with horizontal scaling (scale by adding more machines)

Routing 

    Kafa has a very simple routing approach

Monitor

    Kafka does not have build in tool to monitor.













Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Provision Red Hat OpenShift Cluster On AWS

Implement an event bus on Kubernetes with RabbitMQ using MassTransit in Microservice Architecture Part - 2

Openshift with Kubernetes